TIT BITS ON DISCIPLINE -281
1089. "Even in respect of administrative orders Lord Denning M.R. in Breen v. Amalgamated Engineering Union, 1971(1) All ER 1148 : observed “The giving of reasons is one of the fundamentals of good administration.” In Alexander Machinery (Dudley) Ltd. v. Crabtree (1974) LCR 120, it was observed - "Failure to give reasons amounts to denial of justice" (D.P.S. Rural Regional Bank v. Munna Lal Jain, 2005 AIR SCW 95).
1090. Where the order stated - "I have gone through the charges and the explanation furnished by..... From the material on the file, I am definitely of the opinion that he is not a fit person to be retained. As.... I therefore order that he may be removed....”the Supreme Court observed - "This order cannot be said to be a speaking order. It is arbitrary to the core. Such an order cannot be upheld" [State of Punjab v. Bakhtawar Singh, AIR 1972 SC 2083].
However, no independent reasons need be given in case of affirmance
1091. The Supreme Court has held that where the disciplinary authority concurs with the findings of the inquiry officer, it need not give separate reasons [State of Madras v. A. R. Srinivasan, AIR 1966 SC 1827; Tara Chand Khatri v. M.C.D., AIR 1977 SC 567]. The reason is:-
"The punishing authority has placed reliance upon the report of the Enquiry Officer which means that he has not only agreed with the findings of the Enquiry Officer, but also has accepted the reasons given by him for the findings. In our opinion, when the punishing authority agrees with the findings of the Enquiry Officer and accepts the reasons given by him in support of such findings, it is not necessary for the punishing authority to again discuss evidence and come to the same findings as that of the Enquiry Officer and give the same reasons for the findings." [Ram Kumar v. State of Haryana, AIR 1987 SC 20-43)
1092. In National Fertilizers Lidy. P.K. Khanna, C.A. No. 5460 of 2005 decided on 2.9.2005, the Supreme Court not only re-iterated the principles mentioned above but also held that the decision in Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, (1993)4 SCC 727, does not lay down to the contrary.
However, the Disciplinary Authority should adequately and expressly deal with the points raised by the charged employee in his observations on the report of inquiry.
Post a Comment